Amy chuas parenting memoir, battle hymn of the tiger mother, is sure to be a topic of debate at the cocktail parties of the upwardly mobile. Tiger parenting doesnt create child prodigies, finds. There are all these new books out there portraying asian mothers as scheming, callous, overdriven people. Jun 14, 2016 writing in the wall street journal sub. Jan 14, 2011 by now you may have heard about the excerpt of her book, battle hymn of the tiger mother, that appeared last week in the wall street journal. Amy chua has the diagnosis of american childhood exactly backward. Her previous book, the battle hymn of the tiger mother, and its accompanying wall street journal article made unfounded racial assertions and coined a. Tiger mom, roared onto the pages of the wall street journal, enflaming american parental sensibilities with tales of denying her children playdates, rejecting her daughters handmade birthday card and forcing her to practice piano without bathroom breaks. Tiger parenting is a form of strict or demanding parenting. The excerpt, which had appeared in the wall street journal under the headline. In defense of the guilty, ambivalent, preoccupied western mom. Jewish mother responds to chinese mothers are superior. Battle hymn of the tiger mother summary supersummary.
Amy chua parenting memoir raises american fears time. They frequently fill up multiple sheets of paper with examples from that day, even. Some cultural groups are superior, an echo of the wall street journal headline that whipped up such a storm around her memoir. Strict, controversial parenting style leads to death threats. Its officially the year of the rabbit on the chinese calendar. Chua arrived on the pop cultural map three years ago when an excerpt from her book, battle hymn of the tiger mother, ran in the wall street journal with the incendiary headline, why chinese. Books, shows and movies that capture family lifeand all of the complications. Battle hymn of the tiger mother is a book by american author and law professor amy chua that was published in 2011. Graded 10 exams, wrote three letters of recommendation and blurbed a book. Tiger woman on wall street is a fascinating read on a subject that couldnt be more timely. Jun 11, 2019 but her mom told a different story at the time, praising thennominee kavanaugh in a wall street journal oped titled. It hit a snag in china, where a deal was contingent on excising a chapter about political thought control in the classroom. May 20, 2014 in 2011, yale law professor amy chua provoked a cultural clash with a wall street journal article, why chinese mothers are superior, that advocated a strict approach tiger parenting. A week in the life of the tiger mother amy chua wsj.
Jan 04, 2014 chua, a law professor at yale, became a media sensation in 2011, when the wall street journal published an extract from her book battle hymn of the tiger mother. Ayelet waldman on amy chuas battle hymn of the tiger mother. It quickly popularized the concept and term tiger mother while also becoming the inspiration citation needed for the 20142015 singaporean tv show tiger mum, the 2015 mainland chinese drama tiger mom, and the 2017 hong kong series tiger mom blues. In defense of the guilty, ambivalent, preoccupied western mom ayelet waldman on the virtues of letting kids quit, have sleepovers and find their own way. Chua, a law professor at yale, became a media sensation in 2011, when the wall street journal published an extract from her book battle hymn of the tiger mother.
The essay, summarizing her book battle hymn of the tiger mother in. When cnn called me this week to see if id share my thoughts on the backlash surrounding amy chuas wall street journal article why chinese mothers are superior, i told them i would have much to. Strict, controversial parenting style leads to death. The nonfiction book is considered by some the antithesis of chuas book. The wall street journal recently wrote on its china real time report blog that, although ms.
Battle hymn of the tiger mother hit the parenting hot button, but also a lot more, including peoples complicated feelings about ambition, intellectualism, high culture, the ivy league, strong women and americas standing in a world where china is ascendant. The wall street journal piece, which took excerpts from chuas parenting memoir battle hymn of the tiger mother, ignited a heated debate across the internet this week. Chua said, maybe that particular excerpt in which she proudly describes battling for hours over piano practice with her daughter, not allowing the little girl to use the. Jan 16, 2011 in the week since the wall street journal published an excerpt of the new book by amy chua, a yale law professor, under the headline why chinese mothers are superior, ms. The first wall street journal piece, which took excerpts from chuas parenting memoir battle hymn of the tiger mother, ignited a heated debate across the internet, with critics claiming that the. Tiger parenting doesnt create child prodigies, finds new. Tiger moms dont raise superior kids, says new study forbes.
May 04, 2011 in early january, yale law professor amy chua published a critique of coddling westernstyle parenting in the wall street journal, why chinese mothers are superior. But 2011 might be better known as the year of the tiger mother. That interest is a move in the right direction for. Chua said, maybe that particular excerpt in which she proudly describes battling for hours over piano practice with her daughter, not. The tiger mother talks back the wall street journal. Jan 11, 2014 a lmost exactly three years ago, the wall street journal published an excerpt from a book that remains its most commented article of all time. A lmost exactly three years ago, the wall street journal published an excerpt from a book that remains its most commented article of. The tiger mom effect is real, says large study time. By now you may have heard about the excerpt of her book, battle hymn of the tiger mother, that appeared last week in the wall street journal. They wonder what these parents do to produce so many math. In early january, yale law professor amy chua published a critique of coddling westernstyle parenting in the wall street journal, why chinese mothers are superior. Kims research has been covered by the atlantic, slate, forbes, the wall street journal and national public radio. Raising children the chinese way amy chua, a professor of law at yale, has written her first memoir about raising children the chinese way with strict rules and expectations. The excerpt, which had appeared in the wall street journal under the headline why chinese mothers are superior, was, and still is, an internet sensationas one blogger put it, the.
What book critics say about tiger mother scene asia wsj. While chuas notion of chinese parenting may be outdated, adds juang, her book expanded the conversation on parenting and culture and triggered tremendous interest in the topic. An excerpt in the wall street journal provoked death threats. The phrase tiger mom was coined by amy chua in her book, the battle hymn of the tiger mother, in 2011. They also suggest that the lower median income of the study sample explains why tiger parenting was ineffective. In the week since the wall street journal published an excerpt of the new book by amy chua, a yale law professor, under the headline why chinese mothers are superior, ms. The article, titled why chinese mothers are superior, set off a wave of.
This event discussed different aspects of childraising, in a more nuanced and sensible manner, compared to controversy which the book had previously provoked. Published under the title why chinese mothers are superior, it attracted much controversy. He begins his essay with a reference to yale law professor amy chua, who told of her tiger mom style in a book and a wall street journal article. Jeff yang and amy chua criticize the research for implying that chinese parenting is the same as western parenting. Now, there are too many tigermom varieties to count. The article and book set off a wave of commentary about chuas extreme parenting approach.
Chinese moms in china arent raising superior kids, actually. Nov 21, 2011 he begins his essay with a reference to yale law professor amy chua, who told of her tiger mom style in a book and a wall street journal article. A mustread for western and chinese investors and businesspeople interested in china. The truth about chinese mothers jonathan liu, a core contributor to our companion blog geekdad, offered to share his thoughts with geekmom readers about a topic that hit close to home. Having read the wall street journal excerpt, and decided, like everyone else, that chua was intimidating, impressive and must be stopped, i sincerely hoped the book would be a bore, full of niggly. Amy chua, author of battle hymn of the tiger mother, responds to a new book and a new study that some say challenge the wisdom of harsh tiger parenting. Then su yeong kim released her study concluding that tiger parenting really doesnt work. The term tiger mother tiger mom was coined by yale law school professor amy chua in her 2011 memoir battle hymn of the tiger mother. I admit, my first reaction was a mixture of anger and bitterness, since i recognized much of my own childhood in how amy chua treated her daughters. Kim wong keltner published her new book, tiger babies strike back, just weeks ago. Jan 19, 2012 tiger mom and yale professor amy chua caused an uproar last year with a wall street journal article about the superiority of her strict, chinesestyle version of parenting. Battle hymn of the tiger mother author amy chua talks back wsj. May 15, 20 amy chua, author of battle hymn of the tiger mother, responds to a new book and a new study that some say challenge the wisdom of harsh tiger parenting. But her mom told a different story at the time, praising thennominee kavanaugh in a wall street journal oped titled.
Chua penned a wall street journal essay extolling kavanaugh as a mentor for young lawyers, particularly women. Amy chua, yale law professor and selfproclaimed tiger mom, caused controversy when her article detailing her strict parenting style came out in the wall street journal in 2011. A lot of people wonder how chinese parents raise such stereotypically successful kids. Jim chanos, presidentfounder, kynikos associates we can all learn a lot about finance and investing from tiger woman on wall street. Tiger parents push and pressure their children to attaining high levels of academic achievement or success in highstatus extracurricular activities such as music, using authoritarian parenting methods. Fellow at the johns hopkins institute for applied economics, global health and the study of business enterprise. After her book excerpt about mothering, published this month in the wall street journal, launched a fiery debate online and elsewhere, yale law professor and selfproclaimed tiger mother amy chua.
Jeff yang, a columnist for the wall street journal, writes about amy chuas reaction to the research findings. It seems to take a chinese mother to force my western kids to read the paper. Erin patrice obrien for the wall street journal sophia left and lulu far right were raised by parents. An article in the wall street journal in january of 2011 excerpted battle hymn of the tiger mother. When yale law school professor amy chuas piece, why chinese mothers are superior, appeared in the wall street journal two years ago, i was. She was born in 1962, the year of the tiger, in champaign, illinois. The term tiger mother or tiger mom was coined by yale law school professor amy chua in her 2011. It was the little white donkey incident that pushed many readers over the edge. An exclusive excerpt from amy chuas battle hymn of the tiger mother. Daughter of tiger mom chua picked as kavanaugh law clerk. In early january, the wall street journal published an article by amy chua entitled why chinese mothers are superior, which summarized her new book, battle hymn of the tiger mother. Can we get our children to achieve more, misbehave less and revere us all the way to a sunny graduation day in harvard yard. Tiger mom amy chua responds to tiger baby speakeasy wsj. Jan 20, 2011 when cnn called me this week to see if id share my thoughts on the backlash surrounding amy chuas wall street journal article why chinese mothers are superior, i told them i would have much to.
The article, titled why chinese mothers are superior, set off a wave of discussion around the. Jan 17, 2011 the first wall street journal piece, which took excerpts from chuas parenting memoir battle hymn of the tiger mother, ignited a heated debate across the internet, with critics claiming that the. Feb 01, 2016 amy chua, yale law professor and selfproclaimed tiger mom, caused controversy when her article detailing her strict parenting style came out in the wall street journal in 2011. The tiger mother, americas top parent the new yorker. The tiger mother responds to readers ideas market wsj. In interviews with the san francisco chronicle, the wall street journal, and the new york times, among other outlets, the selfproclaimed tiger mom seemed to. Jan 20, 2011 it was the little white donkey incident that pushed many readers over the edge. A week in the life of the tiger mother amy chua a few busy days filled with lethargic daughters, fluffy yet ferocious dogs and some odd hate mail.
Forget attachment parenting and tiger parenting, its time to take. Review ran an excerpt from amy chuas new book battle hymn of the tiger mother. They wonder what these parents do to produce so many math whizzes and music prodigies, what its like inside. Tiger mom didnt expect this level of intensity abc news. May 05, 2014 the tiger mom effect is real, says large study. Jan 26, 2011 the wall street journal recently wrote on its china real time report blog that, although ms. Thats the name of the piano tune that amy chua, yale law professor and selfdescribed tiger mother, forced her 7yearold daughter lulu to practice for hours on end right through dinner into the night, with no breaks for water or even the bathroom, until at last lulu learned to play. The article, titled why chinese mothers are superior, set off a. Chua has since pointed out that she offers a much more nuanced take on parenting in the book itself.
Chuas january 8 article based on her new memoir battle hymn of the tiger mother unleashed a firestorm of criticism for its unabashed assertion that the harsh stereotypically chinese style. A roundup of critical opinion on amy chuas bestselling book, battle hymn of the tiger. A friend linked me to amy chuas wall street journal article when it first appeared. Retreat of the tiger mother was the headline of one times article. Chua claims that a tough immigrant way of child rearing works well. Erin patrice obnen for the wall street journal amy chua w ith her daughters, louisa and sophia, at their home in haven, conn.
Several new parenting books are upending conventional wisdom by skipping the. Thats the name of the piano tune that amy chua, yale law professor and selfdescribed tiger mother, forced her 7yearold daughter lulu to practice for hours on end right through dinner into the night, with no breaks for water or even the bathroom, until at last lulu learned to play the piece. Daughters of tiger mom share how theyre doing today. Sep 08, 2015 author of the wall street journal s in translation column. The essay, summarizing her book battle hymn of the tiger mother in which she details, among other things, how she raised her daughters in the traditional chinese. The truth about the tiger mothers family life and style. In the book, chua, a yale law professor, defends the. Chuas conviction that hard work leads to inner confidence is a resonant one. Because it is legal in many states to possess tigers with very little regulation and even less enforcement, it creates a legal cover for these illegal activities that have put the wild tiger on the edge of extinction. On march 29, 2011, the wall street journal organized an event called the return of tiger mom in the new york public library. Tiger mom and yale professor amy chua caused an uproar last year with a wall street journal article about the superiority of her strict, chinesestyle version of parenting. Amy chua, the tiger mother, speaks the new york times.
1547 416 435 1333 1545 721 927 397 269 43 394 108 417 1376 752 730 536 815 684 1303 1164 227 916 1183 1122 1069 655 291 1036 1055 1101 18 352